AlexanderGÇÖs Illness at Tarsos
Posted: Wed Oct 12, 2005 7:38 pm
Quintus Curtius Rufus III 5 iii GÇÿScarcely had he entered the water when suddenly he felt his limbs shiver and stiffen. He went pale, and the vital heat all but left his body.GÇÖ
There seem to be two trains of thought as to the nature of AlexanderGÇÖs malady; Engels suggests a malarial attack on the central nervous system (Classical Philology 73 GÇÿA Note on AlexanderGÇÖs DeathGÇÖ 1978 pp224-8) whereas Schachermayer and Green plump for pneumonia.
The symptoms of malaria caused by the plasmodium falciparum include cramping, fever and insomnia it seems but CurtiusGÇÖ makes great play of the suddenness of the attack, and an equally speedy recovery, probably five days this seems far too quick for either malaria or pneumonia.
It is the shock of the cold waters of the Cydnos on AlexanderGÇÖs overheated body that precipitates the attack. The symptoms of sudden and intense muscle pain, pallor, shortness of breath and clammy cold flesh recall nothing so much as a heart attack or most probably angina.
It seems odd that no one should have suggested this before; perhaps the idea of the super fit hero will not allow the possibility of this condition. Later at 5 ix-x Curtius says GÇÿIndeed, the violence of his illness appeared to have abated simply because Alexander realised how serious the situation was. [10] However his anxiety adversely affected his conditionGǪGÇÖ This too seems to fit a cardiac problem for there the best thing to do is relax and not panic; Alexander comes round among his friends gets a grip but thinking on how helpless he is relapses.
Philip the AcarnanianGÇÖs purge will have been effective for psychological reasons, Alexander was a fit young man and his body would mend itself if allowed to. The initial shock of the drug may well have proved fatal as it seems to have precipitated another seizure but either through narcotics contained therein or AlexanderGÇÖs faith he relaxed and his own body went to work. Five days and perhaps a months convalescent killing and fining would be reasonable for recovery from an angiotic attack brought on by the sudden constriction of a narrow blood vessel in the heart due to immersion in freezing water.
There seem to be two trains of thought as to the nature of AlexanderGÇÖs malady; Engels suggests a malarial attack on the central nervous system (Classical Philology 73 GÇÿA Note on AlexanderGÇÖs DeathGÇÖ 1978 pp224-8) whereas Schachermayer and Green plump for pneumonia.
The symptoms of malaria caused by the plasmodium falciparum include cramping, fever and insomnia it seems but CurtiusGÇÖ makes great play of the suddenness of the attack, and an equally speedy recovery, probably five days this seems far too quick for either malaria or pneumonia.
It is the shock of the cold waters of the Cydnos on AlexanderGÇÖs overheated body that precipitates the attack. The symptoms of sudden and intense muscle pain, pallor, shortness of breath and clammy cold flesh recall nothing so much as a heart attack or most probably angina.
It seems odd that no one should have suggested this before; perhaps the idea of the super fit hero will not allow the possibility of this condition. Later at 5 ix-x Curtius says GÇÿIndeed, the violence of his illness appeared to have abated simply because Alexander realised how serious the situation was. [10] However his anxiety adversely affected his conditionGǪGÇÖ This too seems to fit a cardiac problem for there the best thing to do is relax and not panic; Alexander comes round among his friends gets a grip but thinking on how helpless he is relapses.
Philip the AcarnanianGÇÖs purge will have been effective for psychological reasons, Alexander was a fit young man and his body would mend itself if allowed to. The initial shock of the drug may well have proved fatal as it seems to have precipitated another seizure but either through narcotics contained therein or AlexanderGÇÖs faith he relaxed and his own body went to work. Five days and perhaps a months convalescent killing and fining would be reasonable for recovery from an angiotic attack brought on by the sudden constriction of a narrow blood vessel in the heart due to immersion in freezing water.