Alexander the cross-dresser?
Posted: Thu Sep 20, 2012 6:03 pm
Article by Antony Spawforth, in Histos 6:
http://research.ncl.ac.uk/histos/docume ... hippus.pdf
ATB
http://research.ncl.ac.uk/histos/docume ... hippus.pdf
ATB
thanks for the link. A salutary lesson in separating facts from meaning.marcus wrote:Article by Antony Spawforth, in Histos 6:
http://research.ncl.ac.uk/histos/docume ... hippus.pdf
ATB
either I'm misreading your post, or you misread the article: the point of the article is that Alexander did NOT dress up as a God. He dressed in traditional Persian hunting costume, which to Greek eyes looked like garments of a God. Epipphus wanted to discredit Alexander, so he concealed he knew the significance AND abused the lack of cultural knowledge on part of his audience to mislead them.spitamenes wrote:Was this in any way a 'common' practice back in the day? Dressing like a God? Anyone know of other instances? And it didn't seem to emphasize that he dressed as a female God, just the fact that he had a habit of dressing up as God's in general. [
Which would indicate there is a "correct" interpretation. How do you see it?chris_taylor wrote:It's a variation on the misinterpretation of Alexander's attitude towards proskynesis.
Chris.
Perhaps I should have used misrepresentation, ie a selective presentation of facts which distorts meaning. No such thing as a "correct interpretation", only possible interpretations of varying probabilities.Paralus wrote:Which would indicate there is a "correct" interpretation. How do you see it?chris_taylor wrote:It's a variation on the misinterpretation of Alexander's attitude towards proskynesis.
Chris.
Dressing "like a God" in those days depended mostly on what one wore on the head or carried in one's arms as the gods were thought of as wearing the same clothes as humanity -if they were portrayed as wearing clothes, that is. Hence, we (and they) associate Alexander with Ammon because of the images of him wearing the ram's horns; Herakles because of the lion's head, etc. If there was an image of him carrying an owl or image of same, or a serpent entwined staff then we might presume he was emulating Athena or Asklepios. Not that it's likely he would have associated himself with these gods, but I'm sure you get my point. It's already been well explained in this thread that a bow and arrow were attributes of Artemis and the long "dress" was though of as female clothing, thus explaining the wrongly (I also believe) presumed association with Alexander.spitamenes wrote:Was this in any way a 'common' practice back in the day? Dressing like a God? Anyone know of other instances? And it didn't seem to emphasize that he dressed as a female God, just the fact that he had a habit of dressing up as God's in general. And one that was mentioned happened to be female.
I wonder if back in the day they even had a word for 'cross-dresser'. I have been under the (albiet, all too often ill informed) impression that they didn't even have a word to describe gay people.
Nor is it likely that a man recovering from a punctured lung would be jumping on and off a moving chariot, which would place that activity before the events at the Malli town.4 If he were making a march which was not very urgent, he would practise, as he went along, either archery or mounting and dismounting from a chariot that was under way. Often, too, for diversion, he would hunt foxes or birds, as may be gathered from his journals. 5 After he had taken quarters for the night, and while he was enjoying bath or anointing, he would enquire of his chief cooks and bakers whether the arrangements for his supper were duly made. 6 When it was late and already dark, he would begin his supper, reclining on a couch, and marvellous was his care and circumspection at table, in order that everything might be served impartially and without stint; but over the wine, as I have said, he would sit long, for conversation's sake. 7 And although in other ways he was of all princes most agreeable in his intercourse, and endowed with every grace, at this time his boastfulness would make him unpleasant and very like a common soldier. Not only was he himself carried away into blustering, but he suffered himself to be ridden by his flatterers. There were a great annoyance to the finer spirits in the company, who desired neither to vie with the flatterers, nor yet to fall behind them in praising Alexander. The one course they thought disgraceful, the other had its perils. 8 After the drinking was over, he would take a bath and sleep, frequently until midday; and sometimes he would actually spend the entire day in sleep.